Repository navigation
Fold hourly 1241 HIGH into Augustus mental models and jevals - #7
Merged
Merged
Conversation
Fresh PR off main for the 2026-09-19 ~12:41 Boise watch. Do not reopen merged #3/#4/#5. Cards stay backend-agnostic (observe→score→act, ranking ≠ calibration, native vs schema-guided Harbor, collapse late, unofficial toolbelt, life fail-open covers). Soft Noul ≠ hard safety. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
Adversarial pass: SKILL.md mapping-index cell for composition-algebra must appear identically in composition-algebra.md (items 49–61). Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
jsort README is ρ +0.47 (91) / +0.38 (87), not +0.46 (95) / +0.37. implicit_true is included in the yes class, not an unsupported adapter. Keep ZHUBoer/ego-jev off the jiangkoumo hot-click and closed-vote rows. Count is 15 HIGH plus the five-app product cluster. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
Adversarial review — FAIL on
|
| # | Gate | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Invented metrics / unattributed numbers | FAIL → fixed. jsort CommonLit r=0.824 / ρ=0.841 / SMOG 0.661/0.647 / Choice 93% vs Noul 28% match README SHA a7c1f705. Fed hawkish was invented: PR said ρ +0.46 (95 statements) / +0.37; pinned README is +0.47 (91) vs that-day DFEDTARU and +0.38 (87) vs 180-day. Now research/notes.md:14311-14313, references/faq.md:2316-2317. Other theirs numbers checked: groundedness 0.6667 vs 0.7661 / 900/150 / 3,600 / $0.3611 (5cc070d8); playground 254/305=83% / 0/20 vs 3/20 / AUC 1.000 vs 0.750 / 0.0447% / VERDICT 17 ideas 0 promotions / demo-1 zero Jev (96483039 + VERDICT.md); tpellet 36/120 / 66 abstain / 15/20 / 739 ms / 6 ms (b25d81ac); file-search 1,070 / 15 / 7.576s / $0.0209 (b2a236bb); linkmap 566 / 8,460 / 5.95s / $0.27 / 45%→65% / 287/679 (271c1cd2); ORIGIN 961/0 planner / 192+38 (33e6ba07); crawlers n=12 / $0.000035 / dogfood 14/5/0 / U7 unvalidated (2d0b552e + EVAL.md); jevbrain WHITEPAPER N=10000 95.2% / 0.18 ms / $15.36 labeled unverified theater (55fe0abf / WHITEPAPER); jev-mail ~$0.25/20k metadata only (be3211b0); tidy 0.8 + none stay (9211939e); lkclean 70/35/60 Show (1cc18acf pin; live README still those defaults). |
| 2 | Class-table inflation (backend-agnostic ≠ multimodal omni) | PASS after lock fix. Class table only adds “placements / unofficial packaging, not new species” (references/judgment-class.md §90 bullet). No new omni/Archer/multimodal species. Rust SDK “not a new species.” jevbrain local n-gram ≠ TypeSafe Jev ≠ classifier.dev. |
| 3 | Name collisions (ego-jev authors; guard name collisions) | FAIL → fixed. methods-catalog.md Hot-click row (indexed viewport → operation+target, §65 jiangkoumo species) had ZHUBoer appended. ZHUBoer is Ego Lite observe/act + choose + __none__; the agent still plans. Now Hot-click is jiangkoumo-only with ≠ ZHUBoer (references/methods-catalog.md:125); ZHUBoer sits on Computer-use observe→score→act (references/methods-catalog.md:51). Removed ZHUBoer from SKILL Closed-vote cell (SKILL.md:133; agent still plans, not closed-vote). §9 applied-mappings namesake now says “Agent still plans (not closed-vote)” (references/applied-mappings.md:1494). Other locks hold: tpellet/hunch ≠ carldaws/hunch; jev-mail ≠ jevmail; s1_ruby ≠ hunch ≠ feelings; judgement ≠ jevql; groundedness ≠ jev-judge-bench; yuyang ≠ GodsBoy; playground ≠ HF playground. |
| 4 | Archer Hume false positives | PASS. Skip Archer / still NOT landed (research/notes.md:14656-14659; census block). None of the fifteen is treated as the 27B drop. Qwen3.8 ≠ Archer left on main. |
| 5 | Soft Noul as hard gate without envelope | PASS. Thresholds labeled sensors: jsort logits, groundedness 0.5, tidy 0.8, lkclean 70/35/60, hunch 0.5/0.65, file-search 0.8, jevbrain 0.80 (research/notes.md:14649-14653; references/formal-methods.md 1241 envelopes). Envelopes named: Ego Lite locators / __none__ / completed≠success; never-execute + exit 3; none-of-folders stay; pinned/audio/current never closed; Show anyway; ORIGIN pause-if-no-Jev + validResponse sums-to-1; crawlers verify-grounding + review queue. AUTO_ACT is not a Noul. |
| 6 | Silent fallback / soundness theater | PASS. ORIGIN: no production local-policy fallback; pause-if-no-Jev. Hard-gating AUTO_ACT / ranking-as-frequency / pasting 95.2% / 83% plumbing / 36/120 NL2Bash as class ceilings / closing pinned tabs is labeled soundness theater (research/notes.md:14649-14653). Plumbing-green called out (playground 0 promotions). |
| 7 | Duplicate sections already on main after #4/#5/#6 | PASS. Fresh §90. Do not re-fold 1144 / §89. Do not re-card jiangkoumo/ego-jev / carldaws/hunch / fazlerocks/jevmail / pigeonhole. #6 is Pages landing, not a watch fold. |
| 8 | Contradictions within the PR | FAIL → fixed. Banner said “16 + product cluster” with only 15 named HIGH repos + 5-app cluster (20 sources.json adds). Now research/notes.md:14676. Also implicit_true still unsupported contradicted the pinned README/methodology (implicit_true annotations map into yes). Now implicit_true included in yes (research/notes.md:14337-14339 and skill unique fragment). |
Nits (not blockers)
- SKILL trigger list still has bare
undecided? abstain; Detail files use`undecided?` abstain. Pre-existing fragment-hygiene mismatch, not a new species. - Closed-vote mapping cell still says “hot-click cousin: ego-jev” without the jiangkoumo owner (pre-existing on main). The 1241 lock is now explicit on the Hot-click row.
stefw/lkcleanpin is README SHA1cc18acf; live default branch README isf1c740b7. Thresholds 70/35/60 and Show fail-open still match.- yuyang README dates the 10+ call card 2026-09-20; quoted as theirs.
- Playground README scoreboard is 25 rows (7/9/8/0); VERDICT.md is 17 ideas (5 CLEARED / 8 HELD / 4 kills). Both are theirs; do not collapse them.
Parent merges. Ready for parent merge on 4ae5085.
24601
marked this pull request as ready for review
September 19, 2026 19:31
This was referenced Sep 19, 2026
24601
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Sep 19, 2026
* Fold hourly 1541 HIGH into Augustus mental models and jevals Docs-only placement of 9 HIGH receipts into how-to-apply, Harbor-jevals, and mixed architecture. Skip Archer. rh-guard owns injection-firewall / CI-gate cousins; Augustus owns placement. Never reopen #7–#9; do not push onto #10. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Keep sources.json append-only for the 1541 receipts Avoid json.dumps unicode-escaping the existing catalog; add the nine GitHub URLs and bump retrieved to 2026-09-19T21:41Z only. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Remap hourly 1541 off colliding §93 onto §95 Adversarial review of PR #13 FAILed: the fold reused notes §93 / composition items 80–85 / findings batch #76 already taken by merged #10 (jevcache/jev-align) and overlapping open-then-merged #12 (§94 items 82–84). Move 1541 to the next free IDs, restore truncated llama-jev cards, and lock namesakes (orchestrator / jevguard / llama-jev). Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
This was referenced Sep 19, 2026
24601
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Sep 20, 2026
* Fold hourly 1740 HIGH: DGP protocol, jegrep, kev family OOD gap Docs-only placement of System One watch 1740 (Boise ~17:40 MDT / ~23:40 UTC) into notes.md §98, composition items 94–96, and mental-model cards. Skip Archer rewrite. Census not re-derived. HIGH: numerous-com/dgp Decision Graph Protocol (frame→assess→commit; app retains permissions/effects; Jev-first assessor-neutral); can1357/jegrep calibrated path+range Nouls; jaredpalmer/kev family OOD 0.76–0.77 vs Jev 0.86 (architecture delta, not a rewrite of §45). Soft Noul ≠ hard safety. Never reopen #7–#15. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Flag jegrep provider auto-failover as silent FALLBACK Adversarial review FAIL on item 3: can1357/jegrep README auto-fails over OpenRouter↔TypeSafe on 401/402/403/408/429/5xx while still emitting path+range Nouls. Record that as silent FALLBACK (classifier-dev cousin), not operational trivia. Pin --endpoint. Auto-τ-lowering is not a 0.4 proof. beam gate Noul is ranking, not a safety envelope. Replica honesty: kev Score confidence is a stand-in (*theirs*). rh-guard owns the silent-FALLBACK cousin; Augustus still owns protocol envelope / ranking fail-open / replica honesty. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
This was referenced Sep 20, 2026
Merged
Merged
Merged
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Docs-only fold of hourly System One / categorization watch 1241 (Boise ~12:41 MDT) into Augustus how-to-apply, mental models, mixed architecture, toolbelt, and Harbor/jevals practice. Not a thin Jev skill dump. Not a hit list.
PR #3 / #4 / #5 already merged. This is a fresh PR off main. Never reopen merged PRs. Do not re-fold 1144 / §89.
Archer Hume 27B drop is still WATCH (HF empty; tracker likes 49
lastModified2026-09-19T18:37:18Z still promised). Laya yes. Blackwood ABSENT. Census user-provided, not re-derived: SemIf 1846 (+17), jevlike 962 (+3), TypeAR-AI/TypeAR 10 (+1), Awesomejev flat 561/27007.Non-negotiable: exact work stays in code or policy; the model owns narrow judgment; never launder a soft Noul as a proof. Formal methods compose with categorization/scoring; a Noul is a SENSOR. Hard-gating AUTO_ACT, treating ranking logits as frequencies, pasting 95.2% / 83% plumbing / 36/120 NL2Bash as class ceilings, or letting Jev send/delete/close pinned tabs is soundness theater. Soft Noul ≠ hard safety. No wrapper, no SDK/plugin how-to, no copied
TYPESAFE_API_KEY/ZEN_API_KEY/AI_GATEWAY/uv/cargo/ wrangler / chrome unpacked / OAuth client ids / shop URLs /.env. No invented metrics. TypeSafe Jev is the exemplar, not the monopoly. Backend-agnostic categorization/scoring/decision class (Jev-like speed/econ).Lane is Augustus only (mental models / architecture / Harbor-jevals / toolbelt). 0★ HIGHs still get real cards because they were named HIGH.
This update — 18:41 UTC / ~12:41 Boise 2026-09-19 (
research/notes.md§90)Fifteen HIGH repos plus a five-repo product cluster.
1. Observe→score→act (namesake lock)
ZHUBoer/ego-jev (MIT; 0★; README SHA
fc4537ac) — Ego Lite observe/act; Jevchooseover compact page state. Reserved__none__.choosedoes no act and applies no universal cutoff. runWorkflowcompleted≠ success. Exact work local. ≠ jiangkoumo/ego-jev.2. Decision-as-ranking
keltokhy/jsort (MIT; 1★; README SHA
a7c1f705) — pairwise Jev → Bradley-Terry. Scores are relative logits, not frequencies. Noul not Choice for scale. CommonLit r=0.824 / ρ=0.841 theirs. Fed hawkish ρ=+0.47 (91) / +0.38 (87) theirs.3. Native vs schema-guided Harbor
slavadubrov/groundedness-judge-bench (LICENSE MIT / SPDX NOASSERTION; 0★; README SHA
5cc070d8) — RAGTruth QA. Native Noul vs schema-guided LLM JSON. Fastest/cheapest ≠ quality. Jev Macro-F1 0.6667 vs GLM 0.7661 theirs.implicit_trueincluded in yes (world-true still unsupported-by-passages). ≠ jev-judge-bench ≠ jevarena ≠ jevbench.4. 0 promotions / authored vs real
JYeswak/jev_playground (MIT; 0★; README SHA
96483039) — 0 promotions on purpose. A suite that passes a random judge is plumbing (254/305=83%). routing-backtest 0.0447%. ≠ HF playground.5. Offload + classifier-not-generator
yuyang2230/jev-agent-skill (MIT; 0★; README SHA
158ca045) — leftover writer vs cheap decide via OpenCode Zen. Pinjev-1.13-free. ≠ GodsBoy/jev-agent-skill-router.swap-mitra/jev-techstack-classifier (license null; 0★; README SHA
cd32bde4) — ranks options listed instack_config.jsononly. Classifier not generator.6. Collapse late
innocentdiaz/s1_ruby (MIT; 1★; README SHA
6250f97b) — S1 measures;?collapses;undecided?abstains. Code asks; code decides. ≠ carldaws/hunch ≠ feelings.7. Unofficial toolbelt
2389-research/judgement (license null; 0★; README SHA
23c2dcda) — Go CLI.confidence≠ winner p. Pin vs 24h alias. ≠ jevql.community-ports/typesafeai-sdk-rust-community (MIT; 0★; README SHA
bda3ad23) — community Rust SDK. Not a new species. crates.iotypesafeai-sdk-community0.3.1.8. Pointer shell
tpellet/hunch (MIT; 0★; README SHA
b25d81ac) — pick/why/is/run over stdin/PATH/man. Exit 3 abstains. never-execute list. ≠ carldaws/hunch.9. Preview-first VOI / rubric rewrite
emilwagman/jev-file-search (MIT; 0★; README SHA
b2a236bb) — scores not calibrated accuracy. Recall unmeasured. ≠ JevFind.stas4000/jev-linkmap (LICENSE MIT / SPDX NOASSERTION; 0★; README SHA
271c1cd2) — TF-IDF candidates; Jev never sees S2 prose.10. Life fail-open covers
muhammedilyasy/jev-mail (metadata only; ≠ jevmail), MANISH007700/tidy (none-of-folders stay), MANISH007700/tab-bouncer (pinned/audio/current never closed), stefw/lkclean (Show fail-open), jaibhasin/jev-yt-time-saver (Show anyway).
11. S1 decide / S2 plan
JacquesGariepy/ORIGIN-CIVILIZATION (LICENSE MIT / SPDX NOASSERTION; 1★; README SHA
33e6ba07) — Jev every voluntary action; LLMs plan never decide. pause-if-no-Jev.validResponsesums-to-1. ≠ Essentiel-Jev.12. Seed/expand/judge/verify + local daemon ≠ Jev
russfranky/jev-crawlers (MIT; 0★; README SHA
2d0b552e) — risk bands never raw boolean. Verify grounding, not exec.Synxneuos/jevbrain (license null; 9★; README SHA
55fe0abf) — local n-gram/anchor overlap. AUTO_ACT is not a Noul. ≠ TypeSafe Jev ≠ classifier.dev.Files
SKILL.md mapping index unique fragments;
mental-models.mdApply 1241;mixed-architecture.mdfail table + gallery;faq.md;judgment-class.md;validation.md;applied-mappings.md;mappings.md;toolbox-mapping.md;composition-algebra.mditems 49–61;question-design.md;methods-catalog.md;formal-methods.md;agent-self-assessment.md; CHANGELOG / README /docs/ecosystem.md;research/notes.md§90;refresh-log.md;archive/findings.mdbatch #73;sources.json(524 / 521 unique, retrieved 2026-09-19T18:41Z).Checks
evaluate_decisions.py --self-testoksources.json524 sources / 521 unique (3 pre-existing dups unchanged)git diff --checkclean5916012FAIL then fixed on4ae5085: jsort Fed ρ +0.47 (91) / +0.38 (87);implicit_true included in yes; ZHUBoer off jiangkoumo hot-click / closed-vote rows; count 15 HIGH + 5-app cluster.