@@ -416,6 +416,7 @@ \subsubsection{Module Guide (MG)}\label{ssubsec:mg-trace}
416416
417417\end {longtable }
418418
419+
419420\subsubsection {Module Interface Specification (MIS) }
420421\label {ssubsec:mis-trace }
421422
@@ -450,7 +451,8 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
450451This aligned the type names with the notation table and removed
451452inconsistent wording.
452453&
453- Issue \# 265; Section~4.3, Table~2
454+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/265}{Issue \# 265};
455+ Section~4.3, Table~2
454456\\
455457
456458TA Review \# 200,
@@ -462,7 +464,8 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
462464and to improve consistency between the MIS and implementation-facing
463465documentation.
464466&
465- Issue \# 264; Sections~4.4 and~6
467+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/264}{Issue \# 264};
468+ Sections~4.4 and~6
466469\\
467470
468471TA Review \# 200,
@@ -474,7 +477,8 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
474477Added local functions where appropriate and revised module descriptions
475478to better justify the structure of the affected modules.
476479&
477- Issue \# 263; Section~6
480+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/263}{Issue \# 263};
481+ Section~6
478482\\
479483
480484TA Review \# 200,
@@ -487,7 +491,8 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
487491runtime container for the client application and clarified its role in
488492the system.
489493&
490- Issue \# 262; Section~6.1
494+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/262}{Issue \# 262};
495+ Section~6.1
491496\\
492497
493498TA Review \# 200,
@@ -498,10 +503,12 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
498503Revised the introductory text for module decomposition so that it
499504explicitly refers to Table~3.
500505&
501- Issue \# 261; Section~5, Table~3
506+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/261}{Issue \# 261};
507+ Section~5, Table~3
502508\\
503509
504- Peer Review \# 239
510+ Peer Review
511+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/239}{\# 239}
505512&
506513The MIS is missing abbreviations and acronyms needed for readability.
507514&
@@ -511,8 +518,9 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
511518Section~2, Table~1
512519\\
513520
514- Peer Reviews \# 217
515- and \# 218
521+ Peer Reviews
522+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/217}{\# 217}
523+ and \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/218}{\# 218}
516524&
517525Module subsections, module types, and input/output types are unclear.
518526&
@@ -523,8 +531,9 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
523531Section~4.3, Table~2; Section~6
524532\\
525533
526- Peer Reviews \# 212
527- and \# 223
534+ Peer Reviews
535+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/212}{\# 212}
536+ and \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/223}{\# 223}
528537&
529538The level of abstraction and module hierarchy need to be more precise.
530539&
@@ -536,8 +545,10 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
536545\\
537546
538547Final Documentation
539- Issue \# 501
540- (sub-issues \# 481 to \# 485)
548+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/501}{Issue \# 501}
549+ (sub-issues
550+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/481}{\# 481} to
551+ \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/485}{\# 485})
541552&
542553Remove unnecessary text, clarify parameters and outputs, fix
543554formatting, and hyperlink module references.
@@ -552,23 +563,18 @@ \subsubsection{Module Interface Specification (MIS)}
552563\end {longtable }
553564
554565
566+
555567\subsection {VnV Plan and Report }
556568This section summarizes the feedback received on the Verification
557- and Validation (V\& V) Plan and report. It is divided into their respective subsection.
558-
559- \subsubsection {VnV Plan }
560- \label {ssubsec:vnv-plan-trace }
561-
562- This subsection summarizes the feedback received on the Verification
563- and Validation (V\& V) Plan and the revisions made in response. The
564- updates focused on improving traceability, clarifying verification
565- approaches, strengthening test descriptions, and refining the
566- structure and readability of the document.
569+ and Validation (V\& V) Plan and V\& V Report. The updates focused on
570+ improving traceability, clarifying verification approaches,
571+ strengthening test descriptions, and refining the structure and
572+ readability of the documents.
567573
568574\begin {longtable }{p{0.18\textwidth } p{0.26\textwidth }
569575 p{0.34\textwidth } p{0.16\textwidth }}
570- \caption {V\& V Plan feedback and response traceability}
571- \label {tab:vnv-plan-trace }\\
576+ \caption {V\& V Plan and Report feedback and response traceability}
577+ \label {tab:vnv-plan-report- trace }\\
572578\toprule
573579Source & Feedback & Change Made & Where Addressed \\
574580\midrule
@@ -582,7 +588,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
582588\bottomrule
583589\endfoot
584590
585- TA Review \# 130,
591+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
586592annotated VnVPlan.pdf
587593&
588594Traceability table contains unnecessary columns.
@@ -594,7 +600,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
594600Section~4.3, Table~9
595601\\
596602
597- TA Review \# 130,
603+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
598604annotated VnVPlan.pdf
599605&
600606Traceability between test cases and requirements is unclear.
@@ -606,7 +612,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
606612Section~4.3
607613\\
608614
609- TA Review \# 130,
615+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
610616annotated VnVPlan.pdf
611617&
612618Verification approach is ambiguous and difficult to follow.
@@ -618,7 +624,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
618624Section~4.1; Section~4.2
619625\\
620626
621- TA Review \# 130,
627+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
622628annotated VnVPlan.pdf
623629&
624630Test case descriptions are incomplete and include unnecessary columns.
@@ -630,7 +636,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
630636Section~4.1.1--4.1.3
631637\\
632638
633- TA Review \# 130,
639+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
634640annotated VnVPlan.pdf
635641&
636642Unclear whether tests are manual or automated.
@@ -641,7 +647,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
641647Section~3.5; Section~3.6; Section~4
642648\\
643649
644- TA Review \# 130,
650+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
645651annotated VnVPlan.pdf
646652&
647653Descriptions of testing tools are vague.
@@ -652,7 +658,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
652658Section~3.6, Table~5
653659\\
654660
655- TA Review \# 130,
661+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
656662annotated VnVPlan.pdf
657663&
658664Unclear ownership of verification activities.
@@ -663,7 +669,7 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
663669Section~3.1, Table~4
664670\\
665671
666- TA Review \# 130,
672+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
667673annotated VnVPlan.pdf
668674&
669675Usability evaluation is not fully specified.
@@ -675,18 +681,19 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
675681Section~4.2.3; Appendix~7.2
676682\\
677683
678- TA Review \# 130,
684+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
679685annotated VnVPlan.pdf
680686&
681687Ambiguity between SRS walkthroughs and code walkthroughs.
682688&
683- Clarified distinction between SRS verification walkthroughs and code
684- walkthroughs, and placed them in appropriate sections of the plan.
689+ Clarified the distinction between SRS verification walkthroughs and
690+ code walkthroughs, and placed them in appropriate sections of the
691+ plan.
685692&
686693Section~3.2; Section~3.5
687694\\
688695
689- TA Review \# 130,
696+ TA Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/130}{ \ # 130} ,
690697annotated VnVPlan.pdf
691698&
692699Missing list of tables and figures based on rubric.
@@ -697,19 +704,58 @@ \subsubsection{VnV Plan}
697704Contents page
698705\\
699706
700- Peer Review \# 461
707+ Peer Review \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/461}{ \ # 461}
701708&
702709Traceability between VnV Plan and VnV Report is insufficient.
703710&
704- Ensured consistent identifiers are used across both documents so that
705- test results in the VnV Report map directly to planned verification
706- activities in the VnV Plan .
711+ Aligned identifiers and requirement mappings across both documents so
712+ that planned tests correspond directly to reported results, improving
713+ end-to-end traceability .
707714&
708- Section~4.3
715+ VnV Plan Section~4.3; VnV Report Sections~3--4
716+ \\
717+
718+ Issue \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/issues/528}{\# 528}
719+ &
720+ Update tests for implemented features that were previously marked as
721+ in progress in earlier versions of the report.
722+ &
723+ Revised the functional requirements evaluation to reflect completed
724+ implementations rather than listing them under features in progress.
725+ Functional test cases were updated to align with the current system
726+ state.
727+ &
728+ VnV Report, Section~3
729+ \\
730+
731+ TA Review (annotated VnV Report PDF)
732+ &
733+ Some nonfunctional results are marked as \textit {Partial }.
734+ &
735+ Expanded the corresponding nonfunctional sections to clarify the
736+ meaning of partial results and to document limitations and next steps
737+ for incomplete verification.
738+ &
739+ VnV Report, Section~4
740+ \\
741+
742+ TA Review (annotated VnV Report PDF)
743+ &
744+ Computational accuracy test case summary appears incomplete.
745+ &
746+ Completed the computational accuracy subsection by adding a full test
747+ case summary, including method, results, and analysis of AHP outputs.
748+ &
749+ VnV Report, Section~4.4
709750\\
710751
711752\end {longtable }
712753
754+
755+
756+
757+
758+
713759\section {Extras }
714760
715761Our extra is a research paper on the \href {https://github.com/thaafei/DomainX/blob/main/docs/ResearchReport/StateOfPractice_NLP.pdf}{State of the Practice for Open-Source Neural Network Software}. In this research paper, we identified a shortlist of 28 open-source Neural Network (NN) software packages and measured them across 9 qualities to have a pair-wise comparison using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP).
0 commit comments