From de3ea7d81d3cd873cac3ee689447dd56bdad2f7c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Kenan AY Date: Sat, 18 Jul 2026 12:36:05 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] Add Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision --- ...ENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md | 1214 +++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 1214 insertions(+) create mode 100644 PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md diff --git a/PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md b/PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..45a84bdee --- /dev/null +++ b/PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md @@ -0,0 +1,1214 @@ +# Phase-23 Concrete Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment Decision + +This document is subordinate to PHASE 0 - FOUNDATIONAL OATH, +`ARCHITECTURE_FREEZE.md`, the Phase-18 Platform Constitution reference set, +`docs/specs/phase18-platform-constitution/AUTHORITY_DRIFT_GUARD.md`, +`docs/specs/phase18-platform-constitution/TERMINOLOGY_AUDIT.md`, +`PHASE19_RUNTIME_DECISION.md`, the Phase-19 Runtime RFC set, +`docs/specs/phase19-platform-runtime/RUNTIME_EVIDENCE_MATRIX.md`, +`PHASE19_CLOSURE_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE20_CLOSURE_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE21_CLOSURE_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE22_POINTER_TRANSITION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE22_POINTER_TRANSITION_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE22_GOVERNANCE_OVERVIEW.md`, +`PHASE22_ACTUAL_SKELETON_REVIEW_PLAN.md`, +`PHASE22_ACTUAL_SKELETON_REVIEW_RESULT.md`, +`PHASE22_STATIC_PACKAGE_ACCEPTANCE_BOUNDARY.md`, +`PHASE22_STATIC_PACKAGE_ACCEPTANCE_BOUNDARY_CLEAN_RECOVERY.md`, +`PHASE22_STATIC_PACKAGE_ACCEPTANCE_DECISION_PLAN.md`, +`PHASE22_STATIC_PACKAGE_ACCEPTANCE_DECISION_FIRST_BOUNDED_IMPLEMENTATION.md`, +`PHASE22_CLOSURE_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE23_POINTER_TRANSITION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_POINTER_TRANSITION_DECISION.md`, +`docs/roadmap/CURRENT_PHASE`, +`PHASE23_GOVERNANCE_OVERVIEW.md`, +`PHASE23_INITIAL_GOVERNANCE_BOUNDARY.md`, +`PHASE23_EXACT_SHA_EVIDENCE_EXPECTATION_BOUNDARY.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_BOUNDARY_PLANNING.md`, +`PHASE23_RECEIPT_EVIDENCE_BOUNDARY_PLANNING.md`, +`PHASE23_VALIDATOR_OUTPUT_BOUNDARY_PLANNING.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_AUTHORITY_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_AUTHORITY_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE23_EVIDENCE_ACCEPTANCE_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_EVIDENCE_ACCEPTANCE_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md`, +`PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD_CANDIDATE.md`, +`PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md`, +`PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_CANDIDATE.md`, +and +`PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`. +In case of conflict, those documents prevail unless this document is the +narrower Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision for the exact governance-only bounded concrete-assignment +decision boundary identified below. + +**Status:** PHASE-23 CONCRETE ACCEPTED-EVIDENCE SET MEMBERSHIP ASSIGNMENT +DECISION / LOCAL DRAFT / GOVERNANCE-ONLY CONCRETE ACCEPTED-EVIDENCE SET +MEMBERSHIP ASSIGNMENT DECISION ONLY / BOUNDED CONCRETE ACCEPTED-EVIDENCE +SET MEMBERSHIP ASSIGNMENT DECISION BOUNDARY ONLY / NO CONCRETE +ACCEPTED-EVIDENCE SET MEMBERSHIP ASSIGNMENT / NO ACCEPTED-EVIDENCE SET +MEMBERSHIP ASSIGNMENT / NO ACCEPTED-EVIDENCE SET MEMBERSHIP / NO +ACCEPTED-EVIDENCE SET / NO ACCEPTED EVIDENCE / NO EVIDENCE ITEM +ACCEPTANCE / NO VALIDATOR OUTPUT ACCEPTANCE / NO RECEIPT EVIDENCE +ACCEPTANCE / NO RUNTIME IMPLEMENTATION PROCEDURE / NO SOURCE +MODIFICATION / NO CODE IMPLEMENTATION / NO CODE EXECUTION / NO PROCESS +START / NO RUNTIME STATE CREATION / NO PACKAGE INSTALLATION / NO PACKAGE +LOADING / NO PACKAGE EXECUTION / NO DEPLOYMENT / NO CAPABILITY ISSUANCE / +NO TRUST ASSIGNMENT / NO REGISTRY PUBLICATION / NO DISTRIBUTION +AUTHORITY / NO SOURCE ACCEPTANCE / NO SOURCE MERGE AUTHORITY / NO KERNEL +ABI EXPANSION / NO SYSCALL EXPANSION / NO WORKFLOW-THRESHOLD CHANGE / NO +BASELINE CHANGE / NO DEPENDENCY CHANGE / NO RING0 AUTHORITY +**Decision date:** 2026-07-18 +**Decision id:** +`ayken.phase23.concrete_accepted_evidence_set_membership_assignment_decision.v1` +**Decision drafting base main SHA:** +`7a1b5b0210cd045647596c8dbd7d23c1427d6f4f` +**Decision publication subject:** pending separate reviewed publication +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate publication subject:** +`7a1b5b0210cd045647596c8dbd7d23c1427d6f4f` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate PR:** PR #284 +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main ci-freeze run:** `29606701936` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main ci-freeze attempt:** attempt 1 +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main ci-freeze job:** `freeze / 87971563529` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main ci-freeze result:** PASS +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main Dev Loop Validation run:** `29606701940` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main Dev Loop Validation attempt:** attempt 1 +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main Dev Loop Validation job:** +`devloop / 87971563362` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main Dev Loop Validation result:** PASS +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main Dev Loop CI run:** `29606701901` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main Dev Loop CI attempt:** attempt 1 +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main Dev Loop CI result:** PASS +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main smoke job:** `smoke / 87971563189` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main smoke result:** PASS +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main contract job:** `contract / 87971811441` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main contract result:** PASS +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main full job:** `full / 87972227817` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main full result:** PASS +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main isolation job:** `isolation / 87972739254` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main isolation result:** PASS +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main performance job:** `performance / 87973208358` +**Reviewed Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate exact-main performance result:** PASS +**Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment candidate +publication subject:** `e9cb4866ce57240de34ef669b6822097473f9830` +**Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment record +publication subject:** `1d2ec43580e3c919b995365bdb058b852f6b3450` +**Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment record +candidate publication subject:** `c20309a39c91d08dab1df3163a204ab80bc767a5` +**Phase-23 accepted-evidence set membership assignment record publication +subject:** `91a24c007276f1ff8804f6b92bda052f4c16bb2c` +**Phase-23 accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +publication subject:** `f60e093a53865fb2e03ce3ded375ed7bace763e5` +**Phase-23 accepted-evidence set membership decision publication +subject:** `6f8326a895ebdd3e07b4dc73d8be849bfe0df7fc` +**Phase-23 accepted-evidence set decision publication-status sync +subject:** `1e6c2e1af515a57ef2be910dbf6aa61d5fc081ff` +**Phase-23 evidence acceptance decision publication subject:** +`1fe089b141af09e9f98be2a153589e68ab015c18` +**Phase-23 accepted-evidence authority decision publication subject:** +`d9ac910c24601002971e7d06cf94463d739b1358` +**Current phase pointer:** `CURRENT_PHASE=23` +**Accepted Phase-23 concrete assignment decision boundary:** bounded +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary +as a governance decision boundary only; concrete assignment, membership +assignment, accepted-evidence set membership, accepted evidence, evidence +item acceptance, validator output acceptance, and receipt evidence +acceptance remain pending separate reviewed records if ever authorized. +**Authority boundary:** Concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment decision boundary only; bounded concrete assignment decision +boundary only; not concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment, +not accepted-evidence set membership assignment, not accepted-evidence +set membership, not an accepted-evidence set, not accepted evidence, not +evidence item acceptance, not validator output acceptance, not receipt +evidence acceptance, not runtime implementation procedure, not source +modification, not code implementation, not code execution, not process +start, not runtime state creation, not general runtime authority, not +unbounded execution authority, not package authority, not package +installation, not package loading, not package execution, not source +acceptance, not source merge authority, not source repository authority, +not module loading, not workspace runtime, not plugin loading, not +capability token minting, not capability issuance, not trust assignment, +not trust issuer authority, not registry authority, not registry +publication, not publication authority, not deployment authority, not +distribution authority, not distribution execution, not Semantic CLI +authority, not AI Runtime authority, not agent authority, not syscall +expansion, not kernel ABI expansion, not workflow-threshold, baseline, +dependency, or Ring0 authority. + +## Purpose + +This document records a Phase-23 governance-only concrete +accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision after the +clean-fixed Phase-23 Concrete Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment +Decision Candidate publication. + +It evaluates only: + +```text +May a bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision boundary be defined during Phase-23 without assigning +membership, accepting any evidence item, or creating accepted evidence? +``` + +It accepts only the bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment decision boundary as a governance decision boundary. + +It does not create a concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment. + +It does not assign accepted-evidence set membership. + +It does not create accepted-evidence set membership. + +It does not create an accepted-evidence set. + +It does not create accepted evidence. + +It does not accept any evidence item. + +It does not accept validator output. + +It does not accept receipt evidence. + +It does not convert CI PASS results, receipts, validator output, package +review output, source review output, historical results, concrete record +boundaries, assignment candidates, decision candidates, or clean-fixed +claims into a concrete assignment, membership assignment, accepted +evidence, or evidence item acceptance. + +It does not authorize runtime implementation procedure, source +modification, code implementation, code execution, process start, +runtime state creation, package installation, package loading, package +execution, source acceptance, source merge, registry publication, trust +assignment, capability issuance, deployment, distribution, kernel ABI +expansion, syscall expansion, workflow-threshold changes, baseline +changes, dependency changes, or Ring0 authority. + +It does not answer: + +```text +Which evidence item is assigned? +Which accepted-evidence set membership is assigned? +How is accepted-evidence set membership assigned? +How is accepted-evidence set membership created? +How is accepted evidence created? +How is an evidence item accepted? +How is validator output accepted? +How is receipt evidence accepted? +How is runtime implementation procedure defined? +How is source modified? +How is code implemented or executed? +How is a process started? +How is runtime state created? +How is a package installed, loaded, executed, deployed, or distributed? +How is source accepted or merged? +How is a capability issued? +How is trust assigned? +How is a registry entry published? +How is kernel ABI or syscall surface expanded? +How are workflow thresholds, baselines, or dependencies changed? +``` + +Those questions require later reviewed decision or record paths, if ever +authorized. + +## Exact Subject + +This decision draft is based on exact main SHA: + +```text +7a1b5b0210cd045647596c8dbd7d23c1427d6f4f +``` + +That subject is the squash merge of PR #284: + +```text +Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision candidate +``` + +PR #284 changed only: + +```text +PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md +``` + +PR #284 produced post-merge exact-main verification: + +| Evidence | Run / job | Result | +|---|---|---| +| `ci-freeze` | run `29606701936`, attempt 1, job `freeze / 87971563529` | PASS | +| Dev Loop Validation | run `29606701940`, attempt 1, job `devloop / 87971563362` | PASS | +| AykenOS Dev Loop CI | run `29606701901`, attempt 1 | PASS | +| smoke | job `87971563189` | PASS | +| contract | job `87971811441` | PASS | +| full | job `87972227817` | PASS | +| isolation | job `87972739254` | PASS | +| performance | job `87973208358` | PASS | + +The Phase-23 Concrete Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment +Decision Candidate remains bound to: + +```text +7a1b5b0210cd045647596c8dbd7d23c1427d6f4f +``` + +That decision candidate recorded only that a later bounded concrete +accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision path may be +evaluated as a candidate topic. + +That decision candidate was not a decision. + +That decision candidate was not an authority grant. + +That decision candidate did not assign membership. + +That decision candidate did not create accepted-evidence set membership. + +That decision candidate did not create accepted evidence. + +That decision candidate did not accept any evidence item. + +This decision consumes that exact subject as governance input only. It +does not replace, broaden, reinterpret, or supersede the decision +candidate or any earlier Phase-23 governance boundary. + +Missing, ambiguous, stale, inherited, aliased, superseded, or differently +scoped subject readings fail closed. + +## Core Rule + +```text +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision == bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary only +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != accepted-evidence set membership assignment +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != accepted-evidence set membership +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != accepted-evidence set +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != accepted evidence +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != evidence item acceptance +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != validator output acceptance +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != receipt evidence acceptance +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != runtime implementation procedure +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != source modification +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != package loading +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != package execution +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != source acceptance +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision != source merge +bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary != accepted-evidence set membership assignment +bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary != accepted-evidence set membership +bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary != accepted evidence +bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary != evidence item acceptance +concrete assignment decision publication != concrete assignment +concrete assignment decision publication != membership assignment +assignment decision != assignment unless separately reviewed +assignment decision != accepted-evidence set membership unless separately reviewed +assignment decision != accepted evidence unless separately reviewed +assignment decision != evidence item acceptance unless separately reviewed +accepted-evidence set membership assignment != accepted-evidence set membership unless separately reviewed +accepted-evidence set membership assignment != accepted evidence unless separately reviewed +accepted-evidence set membership assignment != evidence item acceptance unless separately reviewed +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision candidate != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision candidate != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision candidate != decision +decision candidate != authority grant +accepted-evidence set membership != accepted evidence unless separately reviewed +accepted evidence != evidence item acceptance unless separately reviewed +accepted evidence != validator output unless separately reviewed +accepted evidence != receipt evidence unless separately reviewed +validator output != accepted evidence +receipt evidence != accepted evidence +receipt evidence != validator output +CI PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +CI PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +CI PASS != accepted-evidence set membership +CI PASS != accepted evidence +ci-freeze PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +ci-freeze PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +ci-freeze PASS != accepted-evidence set membership +ci-freeze PASS != accepted evidence +Dev Loop PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +Dev Loop PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +Dev Loop PASS != accepted-evidence set membership +Dev Loop PASS != accepted evidence +AykenOS Dev Loop CI PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +AykenOS Dev Loop CI PASS != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +AykenOS Dev Loop CI PASS != accepted-evidence set membership +AykenOS Dev Loop CI PASS != accepted evidence +post-merge exact-main verification != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +post-merge exact-main verification != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +post-merge exact-main verification != accepted-evidence set membership +post-merge exact-main verification != accepted evidence +clean-fixed != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +clean-fixed != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +clean-fixed != accepted-evidence set membership +clean-fixed != accepted evidence +publication-status sync != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +publication-status sync != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +publication-status sync != accepted-evidence set membership +publication-status sync != accepted evidence +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != accepted-evidence set membership +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != accepted evidence +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != evidence item acceptance +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != validator output acceptance +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != receipt evidence acceptance +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != runtime implementation procedure +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != source modification +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != execution authority +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != package loading +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != source merge authority +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != kernel ABI expansion +CURRENT_PHASE=23 != syscall expansion +historical PASS != inherited evidence +previous PR evidence != later PR evidence +``` + +The safe default remains no concrete assignment, no membership +assignment, no accepted-evidence set membership, no accepted evidence, no +evidence item acceptance, no validator output acceptance, no receipt +evidence acceptance, no runtime behavior, no implementation procedure, +no source modification, no code execution, no runtime state, and no +package, capability, registry, trust, distribution, deployment, source +acceptance, source merge, kernel ABI, syscall, workflow-threshold, +baseline, dependency, or Ring0 authority unless a later reviewed +Phase-23 decision or record grants a specific bounded authority with its +own exact-SHA evidence. + +Unknown authority readings fail closed. + +## Concrete Assignment Decision + +The Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision is accepted only as: + +```text +bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary +``` + +This decision may define a bounded concrete accepted-evidence set +membership assignment decision boundary, but it does not assign +membership. + +This decision does not create a concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment. + +This decision does not create accepted-evidence set membership. + +This decision does not identify any evidence item as accepted evidence. + +This decision does not accept any evidence item. + +This decision does not accept validator output. + +This decision does not accept receipt evidence. + +This decision does not authorize package loading. + +This decision does not authorize source acceptance or source merge. + +This decision does not authorize runtime implementation procedure, code +execution, process start, runtime state creation, capability issuance, +registry publication, trust assignment, deployment, distribution, kernel +ABI expansion, syscall expansion, workflow-threshold changes, baseline +changes, dependency changes, or Ring0 authority. + +Any later concrete assignment, membership assignment, +accepted-evidence set membership, accepted evidence, evidence item +acceptance, validator output acceptance, or receipt evidence acceptance +requires a separate reviewed decision or record path with its own exact +subject, changed-file scope, non-authorization boundary, and post-merge +exact-main verification. + +## Decision Scope + +This decision scope is limited to: + +1. Accepting the Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership + assignment boundary only as a bounded governance decision boundary. +2. Binding this decision to PR #284 as the clean-fixed concrete + assignment decision-candidate input. +3. Preserving the distinction between a concrete assignment decision and + a concrete assignment. +4. Preserving the distinction between membership assignment and + accepted-evidence set membership. +5. Preserving the distinction between accepted-evidence set membership + and accepted evidence. +6. Preserving the distinction between accepted evidence and evidence + item acceptance. +7. Preserving separation from validator output acceptance and receipt + evidence acceptance. +8. Establishing post-merge exact-main verification expectations for this + concrete assignment decision publication. + +Decision scope is governance text only. + +Decision scope is bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment decision boundary only. + +Decision scope is not a concrete assignment. + +Decision scope is not accepted-evidence set membership assignment. + +Decision scope is not accepted-evidence set membership. + +Decision scope is not accepted evidence. + +Decision scope is not evidence item acceptance. + +Decision scope is not validator output acceptance. + +Decision scope is not receipt evidence acceptance. + +Decision scope is not runtime implementation procedure. + +Decision scope is not package loading authority. + +Decision scope is not execution authority. + +Decision scope is not source merge authority. + +## Current Phase Pointer Boundary + +The current phase pointer remains: + +```text +CURRENT_PHASE=23 +``` + +This decision does not modify: + +```text +docs/roadmap/CURRENT_PHASE +``` + +This decision does not change the active phase pointer. + +`CURRENT_PHASE=23` does not authorize a concrete assignment, membership +assignment, accepted-evidence set membership, accepted evidence, evidence +item acceptance, validator output acceptance, receipt evidence +acceptance, runtime implementation procedure, source modification, code +implementation, code execution, process start, runtime state creation, +package loading, package execution, capability issuance, registry +publication, trust assignment, deployment, distribution, source +acceptance, source merge, kernel ABI expansion, syscall expansion, +workflow-threshold changes, baseline changes, dependency changes, or +Ring0 authority. + +## Decision Candidate Input + +This decision consumes the clean-fixed Phase-23 Concrete +Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment Decision Candidate as its +exact governance prerequisite. + +The decision candidate remains bound to: + +```text +7a1b5b0210cd045647596c8dbd7d23c1427d6f4f +``` + +The decision candidate recorded that it was not a concrete assignment +decision, not a concrete assignment, not membership assignment, not +accepted-evidence set membership, not accepted evidence, not evidence +item acceptance, not validator output acceptance, not receipt evidence +acceptance, and not an authority grant. + +This decision accepts only the later bounded concrete assignment +decision boundary after that decision-candidate publication is +clean-fixed. + +This decision does not reinterpret the decision candidate as concrete +assignment, accepted-evidence set membership assignment, +accepted-evidence set membership, accepted evidence, evidence item +acceptance, validator output acceptance, receipt evidence acceptance, +runtime implementation procedure, execution authority, package loading +authority, source acceptance, source merge authority, capability +issuance, registry publication, trust assignment, deployment, +distribution, kernel ABI expansion, syscall expansion, +workflow-threshold change, baseline change, dependency change, or Ring0 +authority. + +Any concrete assignment decision-candidate conflict fails closed. + +## Relationship To Concrete Assignment Records + +This decision consumes the clean-fixed Phase-23 Concrete +Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment Record and Candidate records +as exact governance prerequisites only. + +The Phase-23 Concrete Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment Record +remains bound to: + +```text +1d2ec43580e3c919b995365bdb058b852f6b3450 +``` + +The Phase-23 Concrete Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment Record +Candidate remains bound to: + +```text +c20309a39c91d08dab1df3163a204ab80bc767a5 +``` + +Those records opened only bounded record-boundary paths. + +This decision does not convert a concrete assignment record boundary into +a concrete assignment. + +This decision does not convert a concrete assignment record boundary into +accepted-evidence set membership. + +This decision does not convert a concrete assignment record boundary into +accepted evidence. + +This decision does not convert a concrete assignment record boundary into +evidence item acceptance. + +Any concrete assignment record conflict fails closed. + +## Relationship To Assignment And Membership + +This decision accepts only the bounded concrete assignment decision +boundary. + +It does not assign accepted-evidence set membership. + +It does not create accepted-evidence set membership. + +It does not define accepted-evidence set membership status. + +It does not define accepted-evidence set membership output. + +It does not make membership assignment inevitable. + +It does not make accepted-evidence set membership inevitable. + +Membership assignment remains separate from accepted-evidence set +membership unless a separate reviewed record explicitly grants that +narrower status. + +Any attempt to treat this decision as a concrete assignment, membership +assignment, or accepted-evidence set membership fails closed. + +## Relationship To Accepted Evidence And Evidence Item Acceptance + +Accepted-evidence set membership remains separate from accepted evidence +unless a separate reviewed decision explicitly grants that narrower +status. + +Accepted evidence remains separate from evidence item acceptance unless a +separate reviewed decision explicitly grants that narrower status. + +This decision does not create accepted evidence. + +This decision does not identify accepted evidence. + +This decision does not accept any evidence item. + +This decision does not define evidence item acceptance procedure. + +This decision does not make accepted evidence inevitable. + +This decision does not make evidence item acceptance inevitable. + +Any attempt to treat this decision as accepted evidence or evidence item +acceptance fails closed. + +## Relationship To Validator Output And Receipt Evidence + +This decision consumes the clean-fixed Phase-23 Validator-Output Boundary +Planning and Receipt-Evidence Boundary Planning records as exact +governance prerequisites only. + +The Phase-23 Validator-Output Boundary Planning publication-status sync +remains bound to: + +```text +d225b2b5ffcd83fe12c70bf0150b60f8f288f329 +``` + +The Phase-23 Receipt-Evidence Boundary Planning publication-status sync +remains bound to: + +```text +9153d858c8ca99b09beb2fa60c6c7bcc565445a9 +``` + +This decision does not convert validator output into accepted evidence. + +This decision does not convert receipt evidence into accepted evidence. + +This decision does not accept validator output. + +This decision does not accept receipt evidence. + +This decision does not grant accepted-evidence membership or evidence +item acceptance over validator output, receipt evidence, package review +output, source review output, historical PASS results, concrete record +boundaries, assignment candidates, or clean-fixed claims. + +Any validator-output or receipt-evidence boundary conflict fails closed. + +## Relationship To Phase-23 Evidence Acceptance And Accepted-Evidence Set + +This decision consumes the clean-fixed Phase-23 Evidence Acceptance +Decision, Accepted-Evidence Set Decision, and Accepted-Evidence Set +Membership Assignment Decision as exact governance prerequisites. + +The Phase-23 Evidence Acceptance Decision remains bound to: + +```text +1fe089b141af09e9f98be2a153589e68ab015c18 +``` + +The Phase-23 Accepted-Evidence Set Decision publication-status sync +remains bound to: + +```text +1e6c2e1af515a57ef2be910dbf6aa61d5fc081ff +``` + +The Phase-23 Accepted-Evidence Set Membership Assignment Decision remains +bound to: + +```text +f60e093a53865fb2e03ce3ded375ed7bace763e5 +``` + +Those records opened only bounded governance decision or record +boundaries. + +This decision does not convert evidence acceptance into accepted +evidence. + +This decision does not convert accepted-evidence set boundaries into +membership assignment. + +This decision does not convert membership assignment decision boundaries +into concrete assignment. + +Any evidence acceptance, accepted-evidence set, or membership-assignment +decision conflict fails closed. + +## Relationship To Phase-23 Accepted-Evidence Authority Decision + +This decision consumes the clean-fixed Phase-23 Accepted-Evidence +Authority Decision as an exact governance prerequisite. + +The Phase-23 Accepted-Evidence Authority Decision remains bound to: + +```text +d9ac910c24601002971e7d06cf94463d739b1358 +``` + +The accepted-evidence authority decision accepted only bounded accepted +evidence authority as a governance authority class. + +This concrete assignment decision does not convert that bounded +authority class into accepted evidence. + +This concrete assignment decision does not convert that bounded authority +class into evidence item acceptance. + +This concrete assignment decision does not broaden the accepted-evidence +authority decision record. + +Any accepted-evidence authority decision conflict fails closed. + +## Relationship To Phase-22 Closure + +This decision consumes the Phase-22 Closure Decision and the Phase-22 +closure publication-status sync as exact governance prerequisites. + +The Phase-22 Closure Decision remains bound to: + +```text +9b19c94a01170d105bd7a7e9fb198df05be17fdf +``` + +The latest Phase-22 closure publication-status sync remains bound to: + +```text +6c0a0c878d54ebc6a768e1c708a68d7eb5898b15 +``` + +Phase-22 remains closed only as: + +```text +actual skeleton reviewed; +static package acceptance boundary defined and clean-recovered; +Phase-21 First Bounded Implementation actual skeleton exact 12-file set +accepted as a static package subject only. +``` + +This decision does not reopen Phase-22. + +This decision does not reinterpret Phase-22 closure as Phase-23 concrete +assignment, accepted-evidence set membership, accepted evidence, evidence +item acceptance, validator output acceptance, receipt evidence +acceptance, runtime implementation procedure, package loading, package +execution, source acceptance, source merge authority, capability +issuance, registry publication, trust assignment, deployment, +distribution, kernel ABI expansion, syscall expansion, +workflow-threshold changes, baseline changes, dependency changes, or +Ring0 authority. + +Any Phase-22 closure conflict fails closed. + +## Relationship To Phase-19 Runtime Authority + +This decision remains subordinate to Phase-19 runtime authority records. + +This decision must not broaden, replace, supersede, weaken, or +reinterpret Phase-19 runtime authority records. + +This decision must not use concrete assignment decision authority to +infer runtime authority. + +This decision must not use accepted-evidence authority to infer runtime +authority. + +This decision must not use accepted-evidence decision records to infer +runtime authority. + +This decision must not use validator-output planning to infer runtime +authority. + +This decision must not use receipt-evidence planning to infer runtime +authority. + +This decision must not use exact-SHA evidence expectations to infer +runtime authority. + +This decision must not use `CURRENT_PHASE=23` to infer runtime authority. + +Any Phase-23 concrete assignment decision reading that conflicts with +Phase-19 runtime authority records fails closed. + +## Not Authorized By This Decision + +This decision does not authorize: + +1. Concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment. +2. Accepted-evidence set membership assignment. +3. Accepted-evidence set membership. +4. Accepted-evidence set creation. +5. Accepted evidence. +6. Evidence item acceptance. +7. Validator output acceptance. +8. Receipt evidence acceptance. +9. Runtime implementation procedure. +10. Source modification. +11. Source acceptance. +12. Source merge. +13. Code implementation. +14. Code execution. +15. Process start. +16. Runtime state creation. +17. Package installation. +18. Package loading. +19. Package execution. +20. Module loading. +21. Workspace runtime or real mounts. +22. Plugin loading or plugin instantiation. +23. Capability token minting. +24. Capability issuance. +25. Registry publication. +26. Trust assignment. +27. Distribution execution. +28. Deployment. +29. Semantic CLI authority. +30. AI Runtime authority. +31. Agent authority. +32. Syscall expansion. +33. Kernel ABI expansion. +34. Ring0 policy movement. +35. Workflow-threshold changes. +36. Baseline changes. +37. Dependency changes. +38. Observability-as-authority. + +Unknown authority readings fail closed. + +## Publication Boundary + +If this decision is published, the publication may change only this file: + +```text +PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md +``` + +The publication must not change: + +1. `docs/roadmap/CURRENT_PHASE`. +2. `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`. +3. `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_CANDIDATE.md`. +4. `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md`. +5. `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD_CANDIDATE.md`. +6. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md`. +7. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD_CANDIDATE.md`. +8. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md`. +9. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`. +10. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_DECISION.md`. +11. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`. +12. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_DECISION.md`. +13. `PHASE23_EVIDENCE_ACCEPTANCE_DECISION.md`. +14. `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_AUTHORITY_DECISION.md`. +15. CI workflows. +16. Baselines. +17. Dependencies. +18. Runtime source or kernel source. +19. Syscalls or kernel ABI. +20. Package loader, module loader, workspace runtime, plugin host, + capability issuer, registry publication, trust issuer, deployment, or + distribution execution paths. +21. `PHASE21_FIRST_BOUNDED_IMPLEMENTATION_ACTUAL_SKELETON_PR_DESIGN.md`. + +Any changed-file expansion beyond this decision publication requires +separate review and fails this decision scope. + +## Post-Merge Exact-Main Evidence Rule + +If this decision is later published, the decision publication subject +must receive its own post-merge exact-main verification: + +1. `ci-freeze` PASS for the exact decision publication SHA. +2. Dev Loop Validation PASS for the exact decision publication SHA. +3. AykenOS Dev Loop CI PASS for the exact decision publication SHA. +4. smoke PASS. +5. contract PASS. +6. full PASS. +7. isolation PASS. +8. performance PASS. +9. Exact changed-file list confirmation. +10. No `docs/roadmap/CURRENT_PHASE` change. +11. No + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md` + change. +12. No + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_CANDIDATE.md` + change. +13. No + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md` + change. +14. No + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD_CANDIDATE.md` + change. +15. No `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md` + change. +16. No + `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD_CANDIDATE.md` + change. +17. No `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md` + change. +18. No + `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md` + change. +19. No `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_DECISION.md` change. +20. No `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_DECISION.md` change. +21. No `PHASE23_EVIDENCE_ACCEPTANCE_DECISION.md` change. +22. No `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_AUTHORITY_DECISION.md` change. +23. No CI workflow change. +24. No baseline change. +25. No dependency change. +26. No runtime source or kernel source change. +27. No syscall or kernel ABI change. +28. No package loader, module loader, workspace runtime, plugin host, + capability issuer, registry publication, trust issuer, deployment, or + distribution execution change. + +Until that exact-main post-merge verification exists, this decision must +not be recorded as clean-fixed. + +Historical PASS results may be cited as context only. + +Failed attempts may be cited as transparent non-clean context only. + +They cannot be inherited as concrete assignment, membership assignment, +accepted-evidence set membership, accepted evidence, evidence item +acceptance, validator output acceptance, receipt evidence acceptance, +runtime authority, package loading authority, package execution +authority, source merge authority, capability authority, registry +authority, trust authority, kernel ABI authority, syscall authority, +workflow-threshold authority, baseline authority, dependency authority, +or Ring0 authority. + +## Later Concrete Assignment Dependency + +This decision is a prerequisite input for a possible later bounded +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment record or decision, +if ever proposed. + +A later concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment record, if +ever proposed, must define: + +1. Exact concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment record + subject. +2. Exact Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment + decision prerequisite. +3. Exact changed-file boundary. +4. Exact concrete assignment scope, if any. +5. Exact accepted-evidence set membership proposed for assignment, if + any, without accepted-evidence set membership status unless separately + reviewed. +6. Exact evidence item reference proposed for membership assignment, if + any, without evidence item acceptance unless separately reviewed. +7. Exact membership-assignment denial or separately reviewed concrete + membership-assignment scope. +8. Exact accepted-evidence set membership denial or separately reviewed + accepted-evidence set membership scope. +9. Exact evidence item acceptance denial or separate evidence item + acceptance scope. +10. Exact accepted-evidence creation denial or separate accepted-evidence + scope. +11. Exact validator-output acceptance denial or separate validator-output + acceptance scope. +12. Exact receipt-evidence acceptance denial or separate receipt-evidence + acceptance scope. +13. Exact runtime implementation procedure denial. +14. Exact package loading and package execution denials. +15. Exact source acceptance and source merge denials. +16. Exact capability, registry, trust, deployment, distribution, kernel + ABI, syscall, workflow-threshold, baseline, dependency, and Ring0 + denials. +17. Exact post-merge verification requirements. + +Until such a later reviewed concrete assignment record is published, no +concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment exists from this +decision. + +Until such a later reviewed accepted-evidence set membership record is +published, no accepted-evidence set membership exists from this +decision. + +Until such a later reviewed evidence-item acceptance record is published, +no evidence item acceptance exists from this decision. + +Until such a later reviewed accepted-evidence record is published, no +accepted evidence exists from this decision. + +Until such a later reviewed validator-output acceptance record is +published, no validator output acceptance exists from this decision. + +Until such a later reviewed receipt-evidence acceptance record is +published, no receipt evidence acceptance exists from this decision. + +## Excluded Local Draft + +This decision does not consume: + +```text +PHASE21_FIRST_BOUNDED_IMPLEMENTATION_ACTUAL_SKELETON_PR_DESIGN.md +``` + +If that file exists locally as an untracked file, it remains: + +```text +untracked +PR-disjoint +not decision input +not evidence input +not concrete assignment input +not membership assignment +not accepted-evidence set membership +not accepted evidence +not evidence item acceptance +not validator output +not receipt evidence +not source authority +not package acceptance +not runtime authority +``` + +It must not be staged, committed, or included in any Phase-23 concrete +assignment decision PR unless a separate reviewed scope explicitly +authorizes that file. + +## Governance Boundary Invariants + +Every later RFC must preserve these Phase-23 concrete assignment decision +invariants: + +1. This decision is bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership + assignment decision boundary only. +2. This decision is not a concrete accepted-evidence set membership + assignment. +3. This decision is not accepted-evidence set membership assignment. +4. This decision is not accepted-evidence set membership. +5. This decision is not an accepted-evidence set. +6. This decision is not accepted evidence. +7. This decision is not evidence item acceptance. +8. This decision is not validator output acceptance. +9. This decision is not receipt evidence acceptance. +10. Assignment decision is not assignment unless separately reviewed. +11. Assignment decision is not accepted-evidence set membership unless + separately reviewed. +12. Accepted-evidence set membership assignment is not accepted-evidence + set membership unless separately reviewed. +13. Accepted-evidence set membership is not accepted evidence unless + separately reviewed. +14. Accepted evidence is not evidence item acceptance unless separately + reviewed. +15. This decision is not runtime implementation procedure. +16. This decision is not source modification. +17. This decision is not code implementation. +18. This decision is not code execution. +19. This decision is not process start. +20. This decision is not runtime state creation. +21. This decision is not package installation. +22. This decision is not package loading. +23. This decision is not package execution. +24. This decision is not capability issuance. +25. This decision is not registry publication. +26. This decision is not trust assignment. +27. This decision is not deployment. +28. This decision is not distribution authority. +29. This decision is not source acceptance. +30. This decision is not source merge authority. +31. This decision does not modify `docs/roadmap/CURRENT_PHASE`. +32. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION_CANDIDATE.md`. +33. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_CANDIDATE.md`. +34. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md`. +35. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_CONCRETE_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD_CANDIDATE.md`. +36. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_RECORD.md`. +37. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_ASSIGNMENT_DECISION.md`. +38. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_MEMBERSHIP_DECISION.md`. +39. This decision does not modify `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_SET_DECISION.md`. +40. This decision does not modify `PHASE23_EVIDENCE_ACCEPTANCE_DECISION.md`. +41. This decision does not modify + `PHASE23_ACCEPTED_EVIDENCE_AUTHORITY_DECISION.md`. +42. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not a concrete assignment. +43. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not accepted-evidence set membership. +44. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not accepted evidence. +45. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not evidence item acceptance. +46. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not validator output acceptance. +47. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not receipt evidence acceptance. +48. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not runtime implementation procedure. +49. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not source modification. +50. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not execution authority. +51. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not package loading. +52. `CURRENT_PHASE=23` is not source merge authority. +53. This decision does not broaden Phase-19 runtime authority. +54. This decision does not reopen Phase-20. +55. This decision does not reopen Phase-21. +56. This decision does not reopen Phase-22. +57. This decision does not expand kernel ABI or syscalls. +58. This decision does not change workflow thresholds, baselines, or + dependencies. +59. Ambiguity fails closed. + +Violation of any invariant fails closed. + +## Architecture Signature + +**Prepared by:** Kenan AY +**Role:** AykenOS Architecture Steward +**Document type:** Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment decision +**Architecture status:** Local draft concrete accepted-evidence set +membership assignment decision / pending separate reviewed publication +**Authority notice:** This signature identifies the architectural +authorship of this decision. It grants only the bounded concrete +accepted-evidence set membership assignment decision boundary defined in +this record. It grants no concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment, accepted-evidence set membership assignment, +accepted-evidence set membership, accepted-evidence set status, accepted +evidence status, evidence item acceptance authority, validator output +acceptance authority, receipt evidence acceptance authority, runtime +implementation procedure authority, source modification authority, code +implementation authority, code execution authority, process start +authority, general runtime authority, unbounded execution authority, +runtime state authority, package installation authority, package loading +authority, package execution authority, source merge authority, trust +authority, registry authority, distribution authority, publication +authority, capability issuance authority, deployment authority, module +authority, plugin authority, Semantic CLI authority, AI Runtime +authority, agent authority, kernel ABI authority, syscall authority, +workflow-threshold authority, baseline authority, dependency authority, +or Ring0 authority. + +## Conclusion + +This Phase-23 concrete accepted-evidence set membership assignment +decision is based on the clean-fixed Phase-23 Concrete Accepted-Evidence +Set Membership Assignment Decision Candidate publication subject: + +```text +7a1b5b0210cd045647596c8dbd7d23c1427d6f4f +``` + +It accepts only the bounded concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment decision boundary. + +It does not create a concrete accepted-evidence set membership +assignment. + +It does not assign accepted-evidence set membership. + +It does not create accepted-evidence set membership. + +It does not create accepted evidence. + +It does not accept any evidence item. + +It does not accept validator output. + +It does not accept receipt evidence. + +It does not authorize accepted-evidence set membership assignment, +accepted-evidence set membership, accepted evidence, evidence item +acceptance, validator output acceptance, receipt evidence acceptance, +runtime implementation procedure, source modification, code +implementation, code execution, process start, runtime state creation, +package installation, package loading, package execution, capability +issuance, registry publication, trust assignment, deployment, +distribution, source acceptance, source merge, kernel ABI expansion, +syscall expansion, workflow-threshold changes, baseline changes, +dependency changes, or Ring0 authority. + +Any later Phase-23 concrete assignment, accepted-evidence set membership, +accepted-evidence, evidence-item-acceptance, validator-output, +receipt-evidence, package-review, source-review, +runtime-implementation-procedure, or non-authorization boundary record +requires its own exact-SHA evidence, changed-file scope, +non-authorization boundary, and reviewed decision path.