Files
hermes-webui/tests/test_issue538_mcp_management.py
T
bergeouss 9806a42a26 fix: protect secrets from masked-value round-trip overwrite (#1237)
- Add _strip_masked_values() to skip masked placeholders in PUT endpoint,
  preserving the original stored secret values instead of overwriting them
- Fix transport badge to gracefully handle unknown/future transport types
  with a fallback that shows the raw string
- Add TestStripMaskedValues (5 tests) for the round-trip protection logic
- Addresses reviewer feedback on secret masking semantics and transport badge
2026-04-29 04:34:55 +00:00

263 lines
9.9 KiB
Python

"""Tests for issue #538 — MCP server management API."""
import json, pytest
from unittest.mock import patch, MagicMock, call
from api.routes import (
_handle_mcp_servers_list,
_handle_mcp_server_update,
_handle_mcp_server_delete,
_mask_secrets,
_server_summary,
_strip_masked_values,
)
def _make_handler():
h = MagicMock()
h.path = '/api/mcp/servers'
h.command = 'GET'
return h
SAMPLE_MCP = {
"searxng": {
"command": "mcp-searxng",
"args": ["--port", "8888"],
"timeout": 120
},
"web-reader": {
"url": "http://localhost:3001/mcp",
"timeout": 60,
"headers": {"Authorization": "Bearer secret123"}
}
}
class TestMcpList:
"""GET /api/mcp/servers — list with masked secrets."""
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_returns_servers_list(self, mock_cfg):
mock_cfg.return_value = {'mcp_servers': SAMPLE_MCP}
h = _make_handler()
_handle_mcp_servers_list(h)
assert h.send_response.called
status = h.send_response.call_args[0][0]
assert status == 200
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_empty_config(self, mock_cfg):
mock_cfg.return_value = {}
h = _make_handler()
_handle_mcp_servers_list(h)
assert h.send_response.called
status = h.send_response.call_args[0][0]
assert status == 200
def test_secrets_are_masked(self):
"""_mask_secrets hides API keys in headers and env."""
masked = _mask_secrets(SAMPLE_MCP['web-reader']['headers'])
assert masked['Authorization'] != 'Bearer secret123'
assert '••••' in masked['Authorization']
def test_server_summary_stdio(self):
summary = _server_summary('searxng', SAMPLE_MCP['searxng'])
assert summary['transport'] == 'stdio'
assert summary['command'] == 'mcp-searxng'
assert summary['args'] == ['--port', '8888']
def test_server_summary_http(self):
summary = _server_summary('web-reader', SAMPLE_MCP['web-reader'])
assert summary['transport'] == 'http'
assert summary['url'] == 'http://localhost:3001/mcp'
assert '••••' in summary['headers']['Authorization']
def test_server_summary_default_timeout(self):
summary = _server_summary('minimal', {'command': 'x'})
assert summary['timeout'] == 120
class TestMcpSave:
"""PUT /api/mcp/servers/<name> — add or update."""
@patch('api.routes.reload_config')
@patch('api.routes._save_yaml_config_file')
@patch('api.routes._get_config_path', return_value='/tmp/test.yaml')
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_add_new_stdio_server(self, mock_cfg, mock_path, mock_save, mock_reload):
mock_cfg.return_value = {}
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'PUT'
body = {"command": "test-cmd", "timeout": 30}
_handle_mcp_server_update(h, 'test-server', body)
assert mock_save.called
saved = mock_save.call_args[0][1]
assert 'test-server' in saved['mcp_servers']
assert saved['mcp_servers']['test-server']['command'] == 'test-cmd'
@patch('api.routes.reload_config')
@patch('api.routes._save_yaml_config_file')
@patch('api.routes._get_config_path', return_value='/tmp/test.yaml')
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_add_new_http_server(self, mock_cfg, mock_path, mock_save, mock_reload):
mock_cfg.return_value = {}
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'PUT'
body = {"url": "http://localhost:4000", "timeout": 60}
_handle_mcp_server_update(h, 'http-srv', body)
saved = mock_save.call_args[0][1]
assert saved['mcp_servers']['http-srv']['url'] == 'http://localhost:4000'
@patch('api.routes.reload_config')
@patch('api.routes._save_yaml_config_file')
@patch('api.routes._get_config_path', return_value='/tmp/test.yaml')
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_update_existing(self, mock_cfg, mock_path, mock_save, mock_reload):
mock_cfg.return_value = {'mcp_servers': {'existing': {'command': 'old'}}}
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'PUT'
body = {"command": "new-cmd"}
_handle_mcp_server_update(h, 'existing', body)
saved = mock_save.call_args[0][1]
assert saved['mcp_servers']['existing']['command'] == 'new-cmd'
@patch('api.routes.reload_config')
@patch('api.routes._save_yaml_config_file')
@patch('api.routes._get_config_path', return_value='/tmp/test.yaml')
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_preserves_other_servers(self, mock_cfg, mock_path, mock_save, mock_reload):
mock_cfg.return_value = {'mcp_servers': {'keep': {'command': 'stay'}}}
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'PUT'
body = {"command": "new"}
_handle_mcp_server_update(h, 'add-me', body)
saved = mock_save.call_args[0][1]
assert 'keep' in saved['mcp_servers']
assert 'add-me' in saved['mcp_servers']
def test_empty_name_rejected(self):
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'PUT'
_handle_mcp_server_update(h, '', {"command": "test"})
assert h.send_response.called
status = h.send_response.call_args[0][0]
assert status == 400
def test_missing_command_and_url_rejected(self):
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'PUT'
_handle_mcp_server_update(h, 'test', {"timeout": 30})
assert h.send_response.called
status = h.send_response.call_args[0][0]
assert status == 400
class TestMcpDelete:
"""DELETE /api/mcp/servers/<name>."""
@patch('api.routes.reload_config')
@patch('api.routes._save_yaml_config_file')
@patch('api.routes._get_config_path', return_value='/tmp/test.yaml')
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_delete_existing(self, mock_cfg, mock_path, mock_save, mock_reload):
mock_cfg.return_value = {'mcp_servers': {'target': {'command': 'rm'}}}
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'DELETE'
_handle_mcp_server_delete(h, 'target')
assert mock_save.called
saved = mock_save.call_args[0][1]
assert 'target' not in saved.get('mcp_servers', {})
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_delete_nonexistent(self, mock_cfg):
mock_cfg.return_value = {'mcp_servers': {}}
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'DELETE'
_handle_mcp_server_delete(h, 'ghost')
status = h.send_response.call_args[0][0]
assert status == 404
@patch('api.routes.reload_config')
@patch('api.routes._save_yaml_config_file')
@patch('api.routes._get_config_path', return_value='/tmp/test.yaml')
@patch('api.routes.get_config')
def test_preserves_others(self, mock_cfg, mock_path, mock_save, mock_reload):
mock_cfg.return_value = {'mcp_servers': {'a': {'c': '1'}, 'b': {'c': '2'}}}
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'DELETE'
_handle_mcp_server_delete(h, 'a')
saved = mock_save.call_args[0][1]
assert 'a' not in saved['mcp_servers']
assert 'b' in saved['mcp_servers']
def test_empty_name_rejected(self):
h = _make_handler()
h.command = 'DELETE'
_handle_mcp_server_delete(h, '')
status = h.send_response.call_args[0][0]
assert status == 400
class TestMaskSecrets:
"""Unit tests for _mask_secrets helper."""
def test_masks_env_values(self):
obj = {"env": {"API_KEY": "***", "PUBLIC_VAR": "visible"}}
result = _mask_secrets(obj)
assert result["env"]["API_KEY"] == "••••••"
assert result["env"]["PUBLIC_VAR"] == "visible"
def test_masks_headers(self):
obj = {"headers": {"Authorization": "Bearer token", "Accept": "application/json"}}
result = _mask_secrets(obj)
assert "••••" in result["headers"]["Authorization"]
assert result["headers"]["Accept"] == "application/json"
def test_passes_non_dict(self):
assert _mask_secrets("hello") == "hello"
assert _mask_secrets(42) == 42
assert _mask_secrets(None) is None
def test_handles_empty_dict(self):
assert _mask_secrets({}) == {}
def test_masks_password_key(self):
obj = {"password": "hunter2"}
result = _mask_secrets(obj)
assert result["password"] == "••••••"
class TestStripMaskedValues:
"""Unit tests for _strip_masked_values helper (secret round-trip protection)."""
def test_masked_env_preserves_original(self):
"""Submitting masked env value should keep the original stored value."""
existing = {"API_KEY": "real-secret-123", "PUBLIC": "visible"}
submitted = {"API_KEY": "••••••", "PUBLIC": "updated"}
result = _strip_masked_values(submitted, existing)
assert result["API_KEY"] == "real-secret-123"
assert result["PUBLIC"] == "updated"
def test_masked_headers_preserves_original(self):
"""Submitting masked header value should keep the original stored value."""
existing = {"Authorization": "Bearer token123", "Accept": "application/json"}
submitted = {"Authorization": "••••••", "Accept": "text/html"}
result = _strip_masked_values(submitted, existing)
assert result["Authorization"] == "Bearer token123"
assert result["Accept"] == "text/html"
def test_new_key_still_saved(self):
"""New keys (not in existing) should be saved even if they look sensitive."""
existing = {"OLD_KEY": "old"}
submitted = {"NEW_KEY": "new-value", "OLD_KEY": "••••••"}
result = _strip_masked_values(submitted, existing)
assert result["OLD_KEY"] == "old"
assert result["NEW_KEY"] == "new-value"
def test_non_dict_passthrough(self):
assert _strip_masked_values("hello", {}) == "hello"
assert _strip_masked_values(42, {}) == 42
def test_empty_dicts(self):
assert _strip_masked_values({}, {}) == {}
assert _strip_masked_values({"k": "v"}, {}) == {"k": "v"}