Skip to content

Report.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
124 lines (88 loc) · 9.37 KB

Report.md

File metadata and controls

124 lines (88 loc) · 9.37 KB
Raw

Codebase Audit Report

职责：本文件是当前有效 Snapshot 下的开发者总览，只汇总已验证 Findings、跨模块结论、未决证据和建议 handoff。权威 Finding 正文见 Findings.md，执行状态见 Dashboard.md。

Navigation

Documentation Discoverability

Field Value
Documentation Hub docs/README.md
Stable Audit Entry docs/audit/Report.md
Status linked
Owner / Action dev-harness-docs / none

Audit does not edit the documentation hub. When status is docs-refresh-required, this table is the exact navigation handoff and does not require an AUD-* Finding.

Snapshot

Field Value
Audit Run codews-20260819-705aff0
Base SHA / Branch 705aff047a1b40b45d6478ee6841a0f3ffc70ccf / master
Context Fingerprint 91941f7e01fae2887ea110260295a3e9a0cc4140ff710e4ffb636d3e756a788d
Audit Scope bin/codews.js, src/*.js, package*.json; documentation and remote systems excluded
Last Drift Validation final output/link gate: valid, Snapshot ddf179...
Cross-module Reconciliation completed

Executive Summary

本次审计覆盖完整 Node.js CLI 主链与 package/HARNESS 边界，确认 10 项问题。最高优先级是三项 P1：无效 base 可执行部分 workspace、配置路径可越界触及 workspace 外部、以及多仓切换失败后没有 rollback。其余问题集中在 force 脏状态门禁、clone 参数构造、状态退出语义、嵌套仓覆盖和工程验证/包元数据。

  • Tasks: 4 completed / 0 blocked / 0 stale
  • Confirmed Findings: P0 0 / P1 3 / P2 4 / P3 3
  • Needs Verification: 0
  • Coverage limits: 远端 Git 服务未访问；AUD-006 的 Windows shell 语义未实测；仓库无项目级自动化验证入口，运行证据来自 /tmp 中可回收的本地 Git fixture。

Architecture / Scope Summary

Context 描述的主链为 bin/codews.js → src/cli.js → src/config.js / src/git.js → Git、文件系统与 hook 边界。审计按 A01 配置继承、A02 工作区安全、A03 切换生命周期、A04 状态与契约 四个行为域贯通 producer、gate、mutation 和 output；没有按文件数量机械切片。

Confirmed Findings

P0

  • none

P1

P2

P3

Cross-module Findings

Boundary Ledger

Boundary Producer / Owner Consumer / Sink Tasks Evidence Status
executable → CLI actions bin/codews.js src/cli.js A04 A04 Result covered
config discovery/inheritance → workspace src/config.js CLI, dirty gate, executor A01, A03, A04 A01, A03 covered
config path → filesystem/Git target workspace producer src/git.js path/Git/hook sinks A01, A02, A03 A02, A03 covered
dirty preflight → mutation checkDirty checkoutWorkspace A02, A03 A02, A03 covered
sequential mutation → success/failure output checkoutWorkspace CLI catch/summary A03, A04 A03, A04 covered
repo discovery/comparison → process status statusWorkspace CLI user/automation A04 A04 covered
package/verification metadata → build/release tooling package*.json, HARNESS.md npm/CI/release consumers A04 A04 covered with command gap
remote Git/platform variants external services / OS shell clone/fetch/pull behavior A03 local probes only explicit gap

Identity and Contradiction Decisions

  • Merged aliases: A01-C01 + A03-C04 → AUD-001; A02-C01 + A03-C05 → AUD-002. No later ID was created for either alias.
  • Kept distinct: AUD-001 vs AUD-005 (invalid producer state vs executor rollback); AUD-002 vs AUD-006 (containment vs shell argument tokenization); AUD-007 vs AUD-008 (exit contract vs discovery coverage).
  • Resolved contradictions: missing-base warning is not repaired downstream; dirty blocking does not contain clean/force escaped paths; targeted commit+depth does not cover default commit-only clone; CLI failure reporting does not roll back earlier mutations; package/CLI versions match, rejecting A04-C05, while lockfile root metadata remains stale.
  • Severity/confidence: P1 ×3, P2 ×4, P3 ×3; all confidence high, no severity changes after end-to-end review.
  • Boundary coverage gaps: remote Git server variants and Windows shell semantics were not probed; AUD-006 is confirmed for the current Unix shell path. No separate security Finding is asserted for intentionally executable post_hooks without a defined config trust policy.
  • Reconciliation Snapshot: ddf17939ff1d0855eddf6c0df61cc43f3bee6450b88647f75b9cc4796b0370ec / Context 91941f7e....

Needs Verification

  • none；所有发布 Finding 已绑定当前 Snapshot、代码/运行 Evidence、反证和已完成 reconciliation。

Rejected / Stale / Resolved

  • A04-C05（“CLI 硬编码版本当前与 package.json 不一致”）已拒绝：两处当前均为 1.2.0。
  • Registry 中无 stale 或 resolved Finding。

Evidence

  • Canonical Context: README, AGENTS, ARCHITECTURE, HARNESS
  • Task coverage: Tasks / Results
  • Finding Registry: Findings.md
  • Cross-module reconciliation: 本报告的 Boundary Ledger 与各 Result 的 Reconciliation Outcome
  • Final workspace validation: runtime.py verify-workspace passed; 11 audit outputs passed validate-output; 17 Markdown files had 0 broken relative links; Task/Result counts are 4/4; 10 Finding headings are unique; git diff --check passed

Recommended Next Actions

Finding / Gap Suggested Handoff Acceptance Direction Audit Action
AUD-001 dev-harness-auto-fix 缺失/循环 base 在 mutation 前失败，并输出继承链 recommend only
AUD-002 dev-harness-auto-fix 所有 repo target 在任何 Git/fs/hook sink 前通过 canonical containment recommend only
AUD-003, AUD-004, AUD-006, AUD-007, AUD-008 dev-harness-auto-fix 分别补齐 force 复检、commit-only clone、argv 执行、status 非零退出和嵌套覆盖回归 recommend only
AUD-005 dev-harness-planning → dev-harness-auto-fix 先确定 rollback/补偿/恢复契约，再做失败注入验收 recommend only
AUD-009 dev-harness-commands 建立基于本地 Git fixture 的 quick/bugfix/full 入口 recommend only
AUD-010 dev-harness-git-workflow 确认发布身份后同步 lockfile 根元数据且保持依赖树 recommend only

本报告不授权自动修复、计划创建、文档修改、命令改写、commit、PR 或 release。