CSIP103 and CSIP107 contradict eachother

[michielvandriessche]

While trying to validate the packages I create I have noticed that is impossible to satisfy both CSIP103 and CSIP107
Where CSIP103 states that there must be a div with the LABEL="Representation" where CSIP107 states that the label must also contain the folder path of te representation.

[karinbredenberg]

Thanks for raising the issue!

This is a dependence related requirement. So if you have more than one representation you need to add the full path as the label. We will look into how to make the textual description better and easier to understand.

[karinbredenberg]

The suggestion is:

• To update CSIP103 and CSIP107 with wording in PR Update to wording for dependent requriments 103 and 107 #750
• Observe that a separate decision for version number of this updated wording will be decided upon the next DILCIS Board meeting.

Board members acknowledgment of the issue:
Tick the box in front of you name to indicate that you have looked at the suggestion.

• Karin Bredenberg (Kommunalförbundet Sydarkivera, chair)
• Anders Bo Nielsen (National Archives of Denmark)
• Anja Paulič (National Archives of Slovenia)
• Arne-Kristian Groven (National Archives of Norway)
• Gregor Zavrsnik (Geoarh)
• Janet Anderson (Highbury Research & Development Ltd.)
• Maya Bangerter (Swiss Federal Archives)
• Miguel Ferreira (KEEP Solutions)
• Stephen Mackey (Penwern Limited)
• Sven Schlarb (Austrian Institute of Technology)

Voting
(Decision making will be carried out on the basis of majority voting by all eligible members of the Board acknowledging the issue. In the case of a tied vote, decisions will be made at the discretion of the Chair)

Tick the box in front of you name to say yes to the suggestion.

• Karin Bredenberg (Kommunalförbundet Sydarkivera, chair)
• Anders Bo Nielsen (National Archives of Denmark)
• Anja Paulič (National Archives of Slovenia)
• Arne-Kristian Groven (National Archives of Norway)
• Gregor Zavrsnik (Geoarh)
• Janet Anderson (Highbury Research & Development Ltd.)
• Maya Bangerter (Swiss Federal Archives)
• Miguel Ferreira (KEEP Solutions)
• Stephen Mackey (Penwern Limited)
• Sven Schlarb (Austrian Institute of Technology)

[jmaferreira]

The new wording has introduced a typo in the text - "requriment".

[karinbredenberg]

5 DILCIS Board members have acknowledge the issue
4 DILCIS Board members agree with the solution

The suggested update of text solution will be included in the next version with an update regarding the spelling based upon four of five saying yes.

Another decision needed for which version this solution will be included in.