Skip to content

Refine Infallibility column to distinguish definitive vs non-definitive teachings #3

Description

@JohnRDOrazio

Context

The current table has an "Infallability" column with values "Infallable" or "-". This binary approach is theologically imprecise per Sullivan, Ratzinger, and Dulles.

Problem

  1. Spelling: "Infallable" should be "Infallible" and "Infallability" should be "Infallibility"
  2. Theological imprecision: The binary infallible/not-infallible framing misses Sullivan's key distinction between:
    • Definitive teachings (irreformable) — which may or may not have been taught infallibly
    • Non-definitive teachings (authoritative but reformable) — which still require religiosum obsequium (religious submission of intellect and will)
  3. Missing nuance on Ecumenical Council documents: Not all Ecumenical Council documents are necessarily extraordinary Magisterium. Decrees and Declarations from councils may carry different levels of authority depending on intent and formulation.

Proposed Changes

  • Fix spelling: "Infallable" → "Infallible", "Infallability" → "Infallibility"
  • Consider replacing or supplementing the Infallibility column with a "Binding Force" column (Irreformable / Reformable) and/or a "Required Assent" column
  • Review whether each document type's infallibility status is correctly assigned (e.g., not all Council Decrees or Declarations are necessarily infallible)

References

  • Sullivan draws sharp boundaries: infallibility is rare and tightly defined
  • Sullivan distinguishes definitive teachings (irreformable) from non-definitive teachings (authoritative but reformable)
  • Ratzinger stresses continuity of truth across all levels but agrees formally on the rarity of infallibility

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions